- SEO Arcade Newsletter
- Posts
- Interview w/ Katie Wagner-Journalism & SEO Are The Power Couple You Need
Interview w/ Katie Wagner-Journalism & SEO Are The Power Couple You Need
Lessons from a Former CNN Anchor Turned Digital Marketing CEO
MEET TODAY’S GUESTKatie Wagner - CEO of KWSM Digital Marketing & Former CNN AnchorKatie spent 15 years as a television journalist before retiring from CNN in 2009 to start her agency. Here's what caught my attention right away: | ![]() |
"For me, the journalistic perspective is sort of the bedrock that hasn't changed. It's just shifted its place in our content strategy. Brand journalism is creating deeper stories around the humans in a business—interviews with our clients, case studies, stats, metrics. It's more about the use case and the examples than it is about features and benefits."
THE INTERVIEW
The Two-Tier Content Strategy That's Actually Working
Here's where it gets interesting. Katie's agency has developed a two-tier approach that addresses both AI overviews AND conversion:
Top Funnel (Educational):
"We create top of funnel content that's aimed at the AI overviews—informational, educational, and not designed to convert. What we're trying to do is get mentioned there because the more you show up in those overviews, the more your deeper content gets seeded in the first page rankings."
Bottom Funnel (Brand Journalism):
"Those brand journalism pieces designed to convert hit people later on in the decision funnel. We get fewer clicks than we have, but most of those clicks will convert because at that point they've got the educational information they need on the SERP, but they're clicking through really only to convert now."
The result? More leads per click than they've ever seen before.
Stop Chasing Traffic. Start Chasing Revenue.
This might be the most important mindset shift for 2025:
"I like metrics just as much as the next person does. But what I really like is revenue. I can tell you for each of our clients, how much revenue we're generating every month, every year—not just how many clicks, how many conversions. I actually need to know that translated into money because that's the ROI we're providing."
Katie's team tracks leads all the way through to paying customers. They have weekly calls with sales teams. They understand profit margins and business models.
"I don't actually care that less traffic is coming back to the website. I care that more of it converts. If we can let go of the ego around getting less click through, this world isn't bad as long as you know how to play in it."
The Case Study That Proves It Works
I shared my experience with Save Fry Oil—a company that couldn't even rank for their own brand name despite being international with real products and paying for ads.
The solution? We created "Restaurant Talks by Save Fry Oil"—a podcast featuring chefs interviewing chefs about operational challenges. Not a pitch-fest. Real conversations.
The result: 248% organic traffic increase in six months, and Google finally recognized they existed as a brand.
Katie's take:
"You're giving a great example of a brand that became brand journalists and put out their own media—content with value in and of itself beyond promoting the product. Can you put out really engaging, valuable content that doesn't necessarily directly promote your products, but welcomes consumers into that ecosystem?"
Near Bound Marketing: Your Secret Weapon
Katie introduced me to the concept of "near bound marketing"—leveraging strategic partners and even your own customers to reach audiences that already trust someone in your network.
"Sometimes the partner is your existing client. If you're doing a case study or testimonial video and leverage that as content, now you're getting in front of their audience and they're like, 'hey, that's Jeremy, and he used Katie's company.' Anytime you can leverage those additional people in your ecosystem, that's the warmest lead you can get."
They even use IP detection and heat maps to track how customers engage with content across multiple visits, mapping the entire journey from first touch to conversion.
The Reality Check We All Need
Here's Katie on the modern marketing landscape:
"Gone are the days when one tactic in a vacuum is going to generate all the business you need. Fifteen years ago when I started the agency, that was true. We could do SEO in a vacuum or digital ads, and it would work. These days, it doesn't work alone. You have to have that entire infrastructure built out."
And this might sting a little:
"Every brand has to be a content creator and they have to be journalists of their own brand and putting out their own stuff or else they're going to get lost in the sea of content out there—either from brands already doing it or from people using AI to create just volume."
What This Means for You
The old playbook is dead. If you're still treating SEO as a siloed tactic focused on traffic numbers, you're fighting yesterday's war.
The new playbook:
Create educational content for AI overviews (build credibility, not conversions)
Create deep brand journalism for conversion (stories about real humans and results)
Track revenue, not just traffic or leads
Build an ecosystem of partners and customers who amplify your reach
Repurpose every piece of content ruthlessly across platforms
As Katie puts it: "This world isn't bad as long as you know how to play in it."
Keep Digging
This newsletter barely scratches the surface. We went deep on:
How to interview customers to reverse engineer your content strategy
Why press releases are still valuable (but not for the reasons you think)
The "create once, distribute forever" approach to content
How understanding profit margins makes you a better marketer
Want the full conversation?
Trust me, it's worth your time.
Until next time,
Jeremy Rivera
Founder, SEO Arcade
Host, Unscripted SEO
P.S. - Katie's agency is doing some really innovative work in lead generation for professional services. If you want to see more of what she's talking about in action, check out her resources page..
